Skip to content

Sam Prendergast and Wiese: ‘There’s got to be a line’ – Lowe

One was cleared, one was banned. Lowe defended his fly-half, felt for Wiese, and then said what many Springboks fans have been saying all week.

Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast points during a Test at the Aviva Stadium
Photo: The Independent

Ireland wing James Lowe is happy Sam Prendergast can play against the Springboks, but has admitted that after Jasper Wiese was banned, “if you want to be fair across the board… there’s got to be a line”.

It is the double standard Springboks fans have been shouting about since the citing hearings, and now it has been conceded from inside the Irish camp. Should Prendergast have missed Saturday’s Test? Tell us in the comments.

Prendergast was cited for a hip-drop tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato in Ireland’s 43-15 win at the Aviva Stadium, and contested the charge at a hearing. He was cleared to play. Wiese, sent off in the defeat to France in Paris, was not.

‘Sammy’s not going around absolutely smacking people’

Lowe, speaking to The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, began by backing his fly-half, while admitting he did not want to “put my foot in it”.

“I don’t think Sammy means no harm in what he’s doing,” he said. “It’s a side-on tackle. I know they’re trying to get rid of it. If you want to make a statement, then you probably do stamp it out there and then. But Sammy’s not going around absolutely smacking people.”

That last line will not go down well in Pretoria. Rassie Erasmus had predicted a “technicality” would get Prendergast on the pitch before the hearing had even sat.

Why Lowe says Wiese’s red came down to fine margins

Lowe then turned to Wiese, whose yellow card on the field in Paris was upgraded to a red.

“He dips his body height,” he said. “I think in the fine print it said he didn’t have control… It’s fine margins.”

READ MORE: Hanekom: Jasper Wiese is ‘the best eight in the world’

An Ireland player concedes the point

Lowe was clear where his loyalty sits. He has “two feet in the Irish camp” and is glad Prendergast is playing. Then came the line Springboks fans wanted: “If you want to be fair across the board, you know, there’s got to be a line.”

The Springboks will be coming for Sam Prendergast

Lowe expects South Africa to test Prendergast physically regardless. With Jack Crowley out injured for the rest of the year, he called Prendergast “the main horse”, and said Fiji had already shown the way.

Every time Prendergast passed against Fiji, Lowe said, he got “a shoulder or a forearm”. “I don’t see South Africa not targeting a 10. If you’re any team and you’ve got a young 10, you go after them, don’t you?”

If Prendergast lights up the Aviva, does any of this matter to Springboks fans? Ireland v South Africa kicks off at 4.40pm GMT on Saturday 21 November.

READ MORE: Sam Prendergast ‘gets gunshy’ when rushed, says SuperSport panel

Springboks vs Ireland: James Lowe Backs Ireland After Rassie’s BanVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Siya Kolisi carries for the Springboks
Next up

Springboks v Ireland: what the Boks need for the final and No 1

There is even a way the Boks can lose in Dublin and still reach the final. Here is every scenario, and how Ireland could end the day as world No…

South Africa · 2 min read

More on Ireland

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?