Skip to content

Schalk Burger’s 11-phase stat exposes the Springboks attack

Two defeats in eight days, both Dublin tries from scrum and maul, and France again in the final. The 2007 World Cup winner explains why the Bok attack has stalled.

Malcolm Marx throws into a lineout for the Springboks against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium
Photo: IOL

Schalk Burger has looked at the Springboks’ last two Tests and found one thing missing: an attack. “We get territory, but we’ve only got a maul and a scrum at the minute,” the 2007 World Cup winner said after the 20-17 defeat to Ireland.

He had a number to back it. In Paris a week earlier, he said, the Boks went through 11 phases and nine of those carries were made by forwards. Dublin, in his words, “was similar”.

Is Burger right, or is the set piece enough to beat France in the final? Tell us in the comments.

Burger says the Boks are in a blip, not found out

Burger was speaking on SuperSport, as reported by Planet Rugby, after South Africa’s Nations Championship defeat at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November. It followed the 21-19 loss to France in Paris and is the first time the Springboks have lost back-to-back Tests since 2021.

Asked whether opponents had worked the Boks out, the former flanker pushed back: “Everyone has a blip, don’t they?”

The real issue, he said, is the attacking fluency. “We create a lot of opportunities, and we’ve got a high error rate,” he said, adding that South Africa have made the second-most handling errors of any team in the competition.

The carries themselves were not the problem. The Boks made 2.7 metres per carry to Ireland’s 2.2, according to our Ireland vs South Africa match report. They just could not turn it into tries.

Both Bok tries came from scrum and maul

Scrum-half Morne van den Berg scored in the 35th minute off the back of a scrum. Hooker Malcolm Marx crossed in the 57th after a driving maul.

Burger said the Boks spent the game “chasing”, and asked whether they could string one good attacking set together. “No, we can’t,” he answered himself. Either the move broke down at source, he said, or the forwards were overplayed.

He also pointed to simple errors just before half-time, one involving Canan Moodie, and a couple of entries into the 22 that let Ireland play where they wanted. Ireland led 17-10 at the break.

Why the Tony Brown attack has gone quiet

Burger linked the slump to the attack Tony Brown built after joining Rassie Erasmus’s coaching staff following RWC 2023. Since then, in his view, the Boks have fallen away and stopped asking enough questions of defences.

At their best, he said, there is a link between the lead carrier and the fly-half behind him that creates width and space. “But you can’t create space if it’s one-off runners,” he said. South Africa had a chance at “a proper smash and grab” in the 78th minute and did not create enough.

He was generous to Ireland. They chose not to overplay, their kicking game was “exceptional”, and wing Rob Baloucoune was “man of the match, rightly so”. Burger singled out the moment Baloucoune took a high ball out of Ethan Hooker’s hands: “It doesn’t happen.”

Read our South Africa player ratings v Ireland for how every Bok fared.

France again in the final, and no Erasmus

South Africa meet France in the Nations Championship final at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, on Sunday 29 November, kick-off 4.40pm UK time. France booked their place by beating Argentina 45-17.

Erasmus is banned for the final. His assistants already had to deny he was in contact with the coaching box in Dublin, as we reported from the Springboks press conference.

France beat this Bok side by two points eight days ago. If Burger’s numbers are right, a maul and a scrum may not be enough a second time.

READ MORE: Springboks v Ireland: what the Boks needed for the final

Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Ireland and South Africa packs locked in a scrum, seen from above
Next up

James Lowe: Springboks win was ‘horrific for the old spectator’

Lowe on the rivalry with no bitterness, the scrum that beat Ireland last time and why he still thinks Ireland win by single digits.

South Africa · 2 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?