Skip to content

Jamie Wall: ‘This is probably the worst All Black loss ever’

The DSPN reporter explains why England 37-12 hurts more than last year’s defeat to South Africa.

All Blacks players walk off dejected after a Test defeat
Photo: Getty Images via The Roar

Jamie Wall was at Twickenham for England’s 37-12 win over New Zealand. The next morning he went one step further than the host. “This is probably the worst All Black loss ever,” the DSPN reporter told the Aotearoa Rugby Pod. Is he right, or is that an overreaction? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: All Blacks player ratings v England

Why Wall calls it the worst All Black loss

Wall said there was nothing to point at: no refereeing rows and no injuries to blame.

He was careful to credit England first. “It was an outstanding English performance,” he said. Then he turned on the All Blacks.

He said this week was meant to be the moment the side restored pride in the jersey after losing to Wales. In his view, they did the opposite.

“And that is so un-All Black-like,” Wall said. “To see them go down like that, it feels like a part of New Zealand rugby kind of died with it.”

He knows last year’s defeat to South Africa is the obvious comparison. He still ranks this one as worse, because of how it happened and when.

The All Blacks barely had the ball

Wall’s view of the first half is blunt. He said England blew three chances inside the 22.

“The All Blacks were lucky they weren’t down by like 40 at half-time,” he said.

He also said it took New Zealand about half an hour to touch the ball. “And by then England had already won the game.”

The host brought numbers: 16 turnovers per 100 carries, against 9.5 for winning sides and 7.3 in New Zealand’s own wins this season. Add 30% territory, 30% possession and a third of lineout jumps lost, and he called them deserved losers.

Wall pointed to the lineout. In his view the locks had been the side’s core strength all year, then made key errors in their one fundamental job. Ollie Chessum folding Scott Barrett in half summed it up.

England say they are just getting started

Wall said the RFU sent eight or nine players through the mixed zone, where players meet the media after the game. The message from all of them was the same.

“Hey, we’re just getting started. We can get better than this,” was the message, as Wall described the mood in the England camp.

He believes them. Ben Earl, he said, will want to beat the 33 carries he made on Saturday.

That is the worry for New Zealand. The two teams meet again at Twickenham on Saturday 28 November (4.40pm UK).

“They now have to play England again and will go in as underdogs,” Wall said. “I mean, they have to be in this game, which is just again completely, completely unacceptable.”

Head coach Dave Rennie has a week to stop the slide becoming a habit.

READ MORE: All Blacks v England rematch: Rennie has seven days

REACTION: All Blacks' Twickenham nightmare
REACTION: All Blacks' Twickenham nightmareVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Ireland players celebrate a try against the All Blacks in Dublin in 2018
Next up

Jamie Wall reveals what Steve Hansen said off the record

The DSPN reporter links a 2018 Dublin memory to a tired All Blacks squad, and says this slump is worse.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?