Skip to content
News

Ben Youngs fires back at NZ fans over Cam Roigard

Youngs on Roigard's long kicks, why nines must defend, and Dan Cole on Ben Earl's game.

Ben Earl celebrates after beating a tackle against New Zealand at Allianz Stadium
Photo: The Independent via Yahoo

Ben Youngs says New Zealand fans told him he was wrong to rank Cam Roigard below Dupont and Lucu. He has answered. “Dupont does not miss that tackle on Ben [Earl],” the former England scrum-half said on For The Love Of Rugby. Is Youngs right? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Ben Youngs on Antoine Dupont’s kicks

Why does Youngs rank Dupont and Lucu above Cam Roigard?

Youngs spoke the day England beat New Zealand 37-12 at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham on Saturday 21 November. He said he had named Antoine Dupont and then Maxime Lucu as his top two nines. “A lot of people in New Zealand were like, ‘What are you on about?’” he said.

He watched Cam Roigard play England. Youngs said he had flagged the New Zealander’s kicking game before. This game, he said, gave him fresh evidence.

“I don’t think it’s as consistent as Dupont’s or Lucu’s, and I thought too often today the kicks were too long,” Youngs said.

In his view, that gave New Zealand no chance to compete in the air. He said they were brilliant at that against Australia in the Bledisloe games, where they dominated the high ball.

“He never put it on the point to allow New Zealand to dominate, and England were able to launch on the back of that,” he said.

Do scrum-halves now have to defend as well?

Youngs said he has mentioned numerous times that nines now play “on both sides of the ball”. He pointed to Dupont’s work the week before.

“He’s holding up Pieter-Steph du Toit, he’s getting over the ball, he’s diving on balls, he’s jackling,” he said.

That brought him back to the tackle on Ben [Earl]. Youngs said Dupont does not miss it, and neither does Lucu.

Youngs does rate the All Blacks nine. His point is about the other side of the game, where he said Dupont is the standard.

Why does Dan Cole say Ben Earl settled the nine debate?

Dan Cole watched the game from home. He spent plenty of time on Earl, who he said got England on the front foot, made tackles and could hit a line.

“Ben Earl, we’ve got to mention him, because the man was outstanding, unstoppable,” Cole said. “There are not enough words to describe how good he was.”

Cole’s praise came in a long answer about the game plan, where he said everyone played well within it. Then he tied Earl’s break straight back to the nine debate.

“And thanks to Ben [Earl], I think we’ve settled who the best nine in the world at the minute is,” Cole said on the show.

In Youngs’s telling, that was the tackle Dupont and Lucu would not have missed. Youngs closed the point with a nod to Roigard.

“Roigard, I’m a big fan of him, but Dupont does it on both sides of the ball, mate. A totally different level,” he said.

READ MORE: All Blacks player ratings v England

England Thrash All Blacks To Make History
England Thrash All Blacks To Make HistoryVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Fin Smith and Marcus Smith of England
Next up

Ben Youngs: Fin Smith could be a doubt for rematch

Dan Cole explains why Marcus Smith fits this backline better than two years ago, while Youngs says the same team should go again.

2 min read

Related stories

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?