Skip to content

Tadhg Furlong Verdict: What Gavin Coombes Told The Panel

Munster’s No 8 was believed. Leinster’s tighthead was cleared. Here is how three judges reached both conclusions.

Munster No 8 Gavin Coombes carries the ball in a United Rugby Championship match
Gavin Coombes in action for Munster.

“I felt someone’s hand come up between my legs and then reach up and grab my testicles.”

That is what Gavin Coombes told the URC disciplinary panel about the Leinster v Munster derby on 24 October. The three judges believed he was honest, and they still cleared Tadhg Furlong. The 22-page written verdict, released this week, says the squeeze he described “could not have occurred”.

Was the panel right, or did Coombes deserve better? Tell us in the comments.

Coombes said the squeeze lasted “2 or 3 seconds”

His written statement, reported by Balls.ie, went further. He said the squeeze “lasted 2 or 3 seconds” and that he said “what the f*ck?”.

After the match he told the Leinster player: “You know what you did.” Coombes said Furlong replied: “Don’t point your finger at me.”

It happened in the 37th minute at the Aviva Stadium, in a ruck after a tackle on Joe McCarthy. It was brought to referee Andrew Brace’s attention in the first half. Neither Brace nor the TMO, the video referee, could find foul play at the time.

Furlong, the Leinster and Ireland tighthead prop, was cited afterwards for an act against the spirit of good sportsmanship. The case has travelled. Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus has already said the gap between Furlong’s outcome and Jan-Hendrik Wessels’ ban “hurt” in South Africa.

Why Tadhg Furlong was cleared despite the footage

The panel was Simon Thomas of Wales, Attie Heyns of South Africa and Pamela Woodman of Scotland. They admitted the clip looked bad. “On first viewing, the video footage appeared to be consistent with the allegation,” the ruling said, according to SA Rugby Magazine.

Frame by frame, they saw something else. Furlong said he was hooking Coombes’ leg to clear him out of the ruck, with his hand cupping the upper thigh for leverage. He accepted some contact may have happened in passing.

The panel put the feeling down to “a static, all-round pressure arising from his own legs closing around the Player’s arm”. Coombes, it said, “honestly, but mistakenly” believed a hand had grabbed him. The two players remembered the post-match exchange differently, so it counted for little.

Munster say their stance on Coombes “has not changed”

The ruling never called Coombes a liar, and Munster are holding on to that. “The priority this week was to back Gavin and for the club to stand behind him, and that position has not changed,” interim chief executive Avan Lee said, as reported by RugbyPass.

The case took a toll on both men. Coombes told the panel he felt “a lot of pressure” because of Furlong’s standing in Irish rugby, and he described something like a “panic attack”. Leinster’s Guy Easterby told the hearing Furlong had been visibly upset by the allegation.

In South Africa the anger is about Wessels. The Bulls hooker was banned for nine weeks, cut to eight on appeal, for a similar offence against Connacht’s Josh Murphy. He was found to have done it. Furlong was not.

Furlong is free to face the Springboks on Saturday

The case is closed unless either side takes it further. Furlong is free to play when Ireland host South Africa at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November (16:40 GMT).

He will not get a quiet afternoon. Steven Kitshoff says the Springboks will go “looking for blood” in Dublin, and Jake White has warned Ireland about the scrum call Erasmus regretted.

Sources: URC written determination as reported by Balls.ie and SA Rugby Magazine; Irish Examiner; RugbyPass.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?