Skip to content

Argentina player ratings v France: Vivas red card proves costly

Argentina led 10-7 and trailed only 21-10 on the hour, then lost Mayco Vivas to a red card and conceded 24 points in the last 20 minutes at the Stade de France.

An Argentina player kicks as Yoram Moefana and Charles Ollivon close in during France's 45-17 win at the Stade de France

Our Argentina player ratings v France follow a 45-17 defeat at the Stade de France on Saturday, in round 6 of the Nations Championship. Argentina had 54% of the ball and won nine turnovers to France’s four.

They still lost by 28. They made 273 metres to France’s 513, missed 20 tackles and gave away 12 penalties, and after Vivas’s red card they were outscored 24-7.

Replacement Pablo Matera is the best of them at 7, with a try and a line break in 37 minutes. Mayco Vivas gets the lowest mark after his red card on 60 minutes with Argentina 11 points down. Tell us in the comments: who was Argentina’s best player at the Stade de France?

Where the Pumas lost it

Justo Piccardo scored on 16 minutes, Tomas Albornoz converted and added a penalty, and Argentina led 10-7 after 23 minutes. Peato Mauvaka’s try on 33 minutes, converted by Gourgues, put France 14-10 up at the break, and Kalvin Gourgues scored and converted on 46 minutes to make it 21-10.

Vivas was sent off on 60 minutes. Six minutes later Julian Montoya was sin-binned, and France scored twice while Argentina had 13 men. Matera’s 71st-minute try, converted by Albornoz, was the only Argentina score of the second half.

Argentina player ratings v France, backs: Cinti Luna’s 51 metres

15 Geronimo Prisciantelli – 6
Carried 12 times, joint-most in the side, for 35 metres, and won a turnover.

14 Bautista Delguy – N/A
Replaced by Rodrigo Isgro after nine minutes. Two carries, no metres.

13 Lucio Cinti Luna – 6.5
Made 51 metres, the most in the Argentina side, and beat two defenders, joint-most. He also made nine tackles and won a turnover, with one penalty conceded.

12 Justo Piccardo – 6.5
Scored Argentina’s first try on 16 minutes. He carried 11 times and made nine tackles.

11 Ignacio Mendy – 5.5
Made 19 metres from nine carries and six tackles, and won a turnover.

10 Tomas Albornoz – 6.5
Kicked seven points, two conversions and a penalty, and made 42 metres from 10 carries with a line break. His 12 kicks from hand were the most on the pitch.

9 Simon Benitez Cruz – 5
Made 43 passes in 46 minutes, but gave away two penalties, joint-most in the side.

Argentina forwards ratings v France: Montoya’s 11 tackles

1 Boris Wenger – 5.5
Made a line break and beat two defenders before going off after 18 minutes.

2 Julian Montoya – 5
Made 11 tackles, the most in the Argentina side, and won a turnover. His yellow card on 66 minutes left Argentina with 13 men, and France scored 12 points while he was off.

3 Francisco Moreno – 5
Seven carries for one metre and four tackles.

4 Guido Petti – 4.5
Won two lineouts, but made one tackle and gave away two penalties in 55 minutes.

5 Tomas Lavanini – 5
Three tackles and five metres from six carries in 40 minutes.

6 Juan-Martin Gonzalez – 6.5
Made 10 tackles, the second-most in the side, won a turnover and a lineout, and played all 80. One penalty conceded.

7 Juan-Martin Scelzo – 6
Made eight tackles and 16 metres from seven carries in the full 80.

8 Facundo Isa – 5.5
Carried 12 times, joint-most in the side, but made only 14 metres. He won a turnover.

Argentina bench ratings: Matera’s try

16 Facundo Bosch – N/A – On for the last three minutes.

17 Mayco Vivas – 3 – Made six tackles, but his red card on 60 minutes, at 21-10, ended the contest.

18 Joel Sclavi – 5 – Two tackles in 25 minutes.

19 Efrain Elias – 4.5 – One carry and a penalty in 28 minutes.

20 Pedro Rubiolo – 5 – Four tackles and a lineout, and a penalty conceded.

21 Pablo Matera – 7 – Scored on 71 minutes, made a line break, seven tackles and 20 metres, and won a turnover and a lineout. One penalty.

22 Agustin Moyano – 5.5 – Made 22 passes and an offload in 34 minutes.

23 Rodrigo Isgro – 6 – Won two turnovers, the most in the side, and made six tackles. One penalty conceded.

Matera, Cinti Luna or Gonzalez? See how the winners rated in our France player ratings v Argentina.

Argentina player stats: Cinti Luna’s 51 metres lead

PlayerMinPtsCarriesMetresPassesOffloadsLine breaksTacklesTurnovers wonLineouts wonPens concededCardsRating
Geronimo Prisciantelli800123580041006
Bautista Delguy90200001000N/A
Lucio Cinti Luna80095131091016.5
Justo Piccardo805111960090006.5
Ignacio Mendy80091940061005.5
Tomas Albornoz8071042150120006.5
Simon Benitez Cruz460617431030025
Boris Wenger1805920100005.5
Julian Montoya6706310011101Yellow5
Francisco Moreno6907120040005
Guido Petti5503310010224.5
Tomas Lavanini4006510030005
Juan-Martin Gonzalez800514200101116.5
Juan-Martin Scelzo80071610080006
Facundo Isa430121430031005.5
Facundo Bosch30000000000N/A
Mayco Vivas430231006011Red3
Joel Sclavi2500000020005
Efrain Elias2801000020014.5
Pedro Rubiolo4000000040115
Pablo Matera37522030171117
Agustin Moyano34031221030005.5
Rodrigo Isgro5402140062016
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Argentina player ratings from the 28-28 draw with the Wallabies in Mendoza: 8.5 for Pablo Matera, a 7 for a centre who was binned, and a 6 for the fly-half.
Next up

Argentina Player Ratings vs Wallabies: Second Test, Mendoza

Argentina player ratings from the 28-28 draw with the Wallabies in Mendoza: 8.5 for Pablo Matera, a 7 for a centre who was binned, and a 6 for the fly-half.

Argentina · 7 min read

More on Argentina

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?