Skip to content

All Blacks Player Ratings vs Wallabies: A 9 For Beauden Barrett

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies from the 43-21 win in Sydney: why Beauden Barrett gets a 9, Peter Lakai an 8.5, and a debutant the lowest mark.

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies: an All Black in the black jersey dives over the line to score a try

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies from Sydney: the official award and the 9 went to different players, and a debutant took the lowest mark.

For 43 minutes, every time the Wallabies left the All Blacks’ 22 empty-handed, the All Blacks went up the other end and scored. Beauden Barrett did it twice, and the second came from 70 metres.

The All Blacks beat the Wallabies 43-21 at Accor Stadium in Sydney on Saturday 17 October to sweep the series 2-0. It was 36-7 at half-time.

Then they stopped. No points after the 43rd minute, and 13 men on the field at the finish.

Barrett with two tries, or Peter Lakai with the seventh-minute turnover and a try: who was your All Blacks player of the match? And should Damian McKenzie’s 4 from 7 off the tee cost him a mark? Have your say in the comments.

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies: six tries in 40 minutes

How to read the marks: 10 legendary · 9 outstanding · 8 very good · 7 good · 6 solid · 5 average · 4 poor · 1-3 disaster. Half-marks allowed.

All Blacks backs: Barrett and Moorby scored four of the seven tries

15. Beauden BarrettFull-back · 80 min

Both tries came straight after a wasted Wallabies attack. The first, on 17 minutes, finished a set-piece move that Lakai broke open. The second ended the half as a contest: he read Max Jorgensen’s pass on 40 minutes and ran it in from 70 metres for 36-7.

A third was on in the second half until Declan Meredith’s try-saving tackle. Roigard had started that counter from inside his own 22.

9

14. Will JordanWing · 40 min

Replaced by Chay Fihaki at half-time. Six tries went in during his 40 minutes without his name on any of them, and he did his job without standing out.

6

12. Timoci TavatavanawaiInside centre · c. 68 min

Named on the bench, then handed the 12 shirt when Jordie Barrett was ruled out on match day with a tight calf. His line break three minutes into the second half made Moorby’s second try.

He went off injured on 68 minutes with the bench already used, and the All Blacks played on with 14.

7

11. Josh MoorbyWing · 80 min

Two tries on his first start of the series. He backed up Codie Taylor’s second line break for the opener on 12 minutes, then finished Tavatavanawai’s break on 43.

Those were the All Blacks’ first points and their last.

8

10. Damian McKenzieFly-half · 80 min

Ran the game from the first minute to the last, and the forwards attacked off his calls all night. The blemish is the tee: 4 from 7, with the conversions on 12, 17 and 26 minutes missed.

Six points went begging, which costs nothing in a 43-21 win and would cost plenty against the Springboks.

8

9. Cam RoigardScrum-half · c. 67 min

A week after his 9 at Eden Park, he made 16 successful passes inside 19 minutes. The speed of that service set the tempo for everything else.

He also saved a try on 62 minutes. Meredith was reaching out to score when Roigard got a boot to the ball, and the TMO found no foul play.

Then he ran the counter from his own 22 that so nearly gave Barrett a third. Cortez Ratima replaced him on 67.

8.5

All Blacks forwards: Lakai’s seventh-minute turnover turned the match

8. Wallace SititiNo 8 · c. 55 min

The first scrum of the match did not come until the 32nd minute, and Sititi scored off it from five metres. Jeremy Williams had gone to the bin a minute earlier. Shannon Frizell replaced him on 55.

7.5

7. Peter LakaiOpenside flanker · 80 min

The Wallabies had gone through 13 phases on the All Blacks’ line when Lakai won the turnover inside his own 22 on seven minutes. Turnovers like that deserve a column of their own on the scoresheet.

Ten minutes later his line break made Barrett’s first try, and on 21 he scored his own after a TMO check. Three defenders beaten inside 19 minutes. Rugby Australia named him player of the match.

8.5

6. Tupou Vaa’iBlindside flanker · 80 min

Eighty minutes in a pack that won the physical battle, without a single moment that stood out either way.

6

5. Fabian HollandLock · 80 min

In to partner Scott Barrett, and he saw out the full game without a moment that moves the mark.

6

4. Scott BarrettLock · 80 min

Eighty minutes alongside Holland in a dominant pack, and a 6 for a solid night.

6

3. Fletcher NewellTighthead prop · c. 49 min

A tighthead is judged at the scrum, and there was no scrum until the 32nd minute. Off with the rest of the front row on 49.

6

2. Codie Taylor (c)Hooker · c. 60 min

Two very good line breaks in the first quarter, and the second put Moorby away for the opening try. He led a pack that dominated physically.

Replaced on 49 minutes, he was back on at 68 after Samisoni Taukei’aho went off, and he finished the game.

8

1. George BowerLoosehead prop · c. 49 min

Promoted from the bench to start. His first scrum produced Sititi’s try, which is about the extent of the set-piece evidence.

6

All Blacks replacements: Fihaki’s debut brought a line break, a fumble and a yellow card

23. Rieko IoaneOutside centre · c. 78 min

On inside two minutes for Quinn Tupaea, so this was a starter’s shift in everything but the number. He took the ball on the end of the line on 26 minutes and was too strong for Tom Wright for the fourth try.

7

22. Chay FihakiWing · 40 min

A Test debut from half-time, in place of Jordan. He made a line break, then could not gather his own grubber.

With four minutes left he was sent to the bin for head-on-head contact with Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii. Tavatavanawai was already off with the bench empty, so the All Blacks finished with 13.

5

16. Samisoni Taukei’ahoHooker · c. 18 min

Replaced Taylor at 49. Held up over the Wallabies’ line on 66, and the Wallabies scored from the drop-out. He went off a minute later.

6

17. Xavier NumiaLoosehead prop · c. 31 min

On for Bower at 49 and played out a second half the All Blacks lost 14-7.

6

18. Pasilio TosiTighthead prop · c. 31 min

Came on with Numia at 49 and finished the game at tighthead.

6

19. Shannon FrizellFlanker · c. 6 min

On for Sititi at 55, and off six minutes later with what looked like a lower-leg injury.

6

20. Du’Plessis KirifiFlanker · c. 20 min

Replaced Frizell on 61 and saw out the last 20 minutes quietly.

6

21. Cortez RatimaScrum-half · c. 13 min

Thirteen minutes at the end, with 14 men and then 13 in front of him.

6

Not rated: 13 Quinn Tupaea (off for an HIA inside two minutes, failed it at 23).

Barrett gets the 9, and Lakai’s turnover is the only argument against it

Player of the match: Beauden Barrett (9/10). His two tries turned Wallabies mistakes into 12 points, and the second took the game away before half-time. He is a two-time world player of the year on the list of the 30 best players in the world.

Runner-up: Peter Lakai (8.5/10). Rugby Australia gave him the official award, and the seventh-minute turnover is a fair reason. Roigard, also on 8.5, loses the tie-break: his try-saver came at 43-14, Lakai’s turnover at 0-0.

Barrett or Lakai? Pick one in the comments.

Why did the All Blacks stop scoring after 43 minutes?

The changes came early. Fihaki replaced Jordan at half-time, and the whole front row was changed on 49 minutes. From that point the Wallabies won the game 14-0.

Frizell lasted six minutes. When Tavatavanawai went off on 68 there was nobody left to send on.

The moment that flipped the first-half pattern came on 66 minutes. Taukei’aho was held up over the line, and the Wallabies ran the drop-out back the length of the field for Daugunu’s try. For once, a wasted visit to the 22 cost the All Blacks.

Taylor told Nine his side “were awesome in that first 40”. Then: “That second 40 was a bit different.” It finished 14-7 to Australia, with a debutant in the bin.

The McKenzie-Roigard axis ran the game, and the Springboks should test it

Nick Phipps, the former Wallabies scrum-half, was on ABC’s commentary. Early in the first half he said “the speed of service at the breakdown from the All Blacks was too quick.”

The broadcast numbers at 34 minutes show what that speed bought. Six entries to the Wallabies’ 22, at 4.8 points a visit.

Nobody in gold slowed that ball down. The Springboks are the side to try it against next.

43-21, and the Wallabies still broke the line more often

Full time: New Zealand 43-21 Australia (half-time 36-7), Accor Stadium, Sydney, Saturday 17 October 2026. Attendance 73,399.

New Zealand 43. Tries: Josh Moorby 2, Beauden Barrett 2, Peter Lakai, Rieko Ioane, Wallace Sititi. Conversions: Damian McKenzie 4 from 7.

Australia 21. Tries: Jeremy Williams, Tom Wright, Filipo Daugunu. Conversions: Ryan Lonergan 2, Declan Meredith 1.

Yellow cards: Jeremy Williams (31 minutes), Chay Fihaki (76). Referee: Luke Pearce (England). TMO: Marius van der Westhuizen (South Africa).

At 43-7 the Wallabies led the line breaks 6-4 and had spent longer in the opposition 22, 3:40 to 2:51. New Zealand still took 5.4 points a visit to their 1.4. It is a 13th straight All Blacks win over the Wallabies.

Minutes: ABC’s live blog and Opta. Player of the match: Rugby Australia.

Is a 5 too harsh on a debutant who made a line break before the card? Make your case in the comments.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii on the wing for the Wallabies ahead of the Bledisloe Cup Test at Eden Park
Next up

Wallabies team: Isaac Henry at 13, and why Suaalii stays wide

The Wallabies team for Eden Park has one change, Isaac Henry at 13, and keeps Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii on the wing. The reason is the All Blacks back three.

Australia · 3 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?