Skip to content

All Blacks Player Ratings vs Wallabies: A 9 For Cam Roigard

The All Blacks won the second half 33-5 to keep the Bledisloe Cup for a 24th straight year and stretch their unbeaten run at Eden Park to 54 Tests.

All Blacks player ratings from Eden Park: Cam Roigard's hand in four tries earns a 9, and seven All Blacks go unrated.

All Blacks player ratings from Eden Park: Cam Roigard’s hand in four tries earns a 9, and Damian McKenzie gets an 8.5.

“I think we’re going to win 36-34,” Jeremy Paul said of the Wallabies on Monday. Kieran Read, Justin Marshall and Andy Rowe all tipped the All Blacks by 17. They won by 31.

It was 17-14 at half-time. Then New Zealand ran in 26 unanswered points and won 50-19, seven tries to three. The Bledisloe Cup stays in New Zealand for a 24th straight year.

Every All Black who took the field is rated below, with the evidence behind each mark.

Who was your All Blacks man of the match? Tell us in the comments.

All Blacks player ratings: Roigard and McKenzie lead the marks

How to read the marks: 6 is a competent Test performance. NR means we couldn’t find enough to score a player fairly.

All Blacks backs: the halves had a hand in five of seven tries

15. Beauden BarrettFull-back · 80 min

8

14. Will JordanWing · 80 min

Opta logged two line breaks. The second, early in the second half, should have produced a try, but his attempted link with Sititi was picked off by Lonergan. He finished the night by hacking on a loose Australian ball and outpacing everyone to it. One first-half turnover conceded.

7

13. Quinn TupaeaOutside centre · 80 min

Won two breakdown penalties, one of them on 59 minutes when Harry Potter was isolated as Australia tried to run from their own 22. That is a back-rower’s return from a centre, in a week when Justin Marshall questioned the All Blacks’ turnover threat. Six first-half carries.

7.5

12. Jordie BarrettInside centre · c.69 min

Won back the high ball that started Lakai’s try and broke the line in the same move. Nine tackles completed by half-time, one of them dominant, plus seven carries. Sky Sports also credited him with a key role in Carter’s try. Replaced by Rieko Ioane with 11 minutes left.

8

11. Leroy CarterWing · c.67 min

Scored New Zealand’s fifth try, breaking the line and dragging defenders over with him. He was hurt in the act, his ankle trapped under Valetini, and limped off soon after. Beyond that the evidence is thin: two first-half carries.

6.5

10. Damian McKenzieFly-half · 80 min

Paul said the Wallabies’ 10 needed a blinder. New Zealand’s had one: 15 points from seven of eight kicks at goal, missing only the conversion of Moorby’s try. He made New Zealand’s first try, cutting through and drawing the full-back before sending Lakai over. He only started at 10 because Ruben Love and Richie Mo’unga were injured.

8.5

9. Cam RoigardScrum-half · c.69 min

Involved in four of the five tries New Zealand scored while he was on. He gave the final pass for Vaa’i and Taylor and sniped over himself when Australia stopped the maul. Carter’s try came off his inside ball.

9

All Blacks forwards: three of them scored

8. Wallace SititiNo 8 · c.54 min

The busiest carrier on the field at half-time with 11, and his line break set up Vaa’i’s try. Replaced after 52 minutes, he came back on for the closing stages when Anton Segner went off for a head injury assessment (HIA).

7.5

7. Peter LakaiOpenside flanker · 80 min

Finished McKenzie’s break for the first All Blacks try and had a hand in Carter’s down the left. Opta also credits him with a first-half turnover. One slip: his touch on Wright’s kick turned an Australian error into an Australian lineout in New Zealand territory.

8

6. Tupou Vaa’iBlindside flanker · 80 min

Scored the second try after New Zealand worked their way out of their own 22. Opta logged two line breaks, the second in the build-up to Carter’s try. Six first-half carries. His lineout work wasn’t covered.

7.5

5. Josh LordLock · c.67 min

His clearest moment was stealing a deep Australian lineout just before the hour to set up another attack. Replaced after 58 minutes, he returned when Scott Barrett went off for an HIA. Two first-half carries; little else is visible.

6.5

4. Scott BarrettLock · c.71 min

Busy in his first Test of the year: seven carries and a dominant tackle by half-time. He went off for an HIA around 71 minutes and failed it. New Zealand lost two of six first-half lineouts, but the reports don’t say who was targeted.

6.5

3. Fletcher NewellTighthead prop · c.58 min

Four first-half carries in 58 minutes. A tighthead earns his money at scrum time, and the reports barely touch the scrums.

6.5

2. Codie Taylor (c)Hooker · c.57 min

Captained a dominant second half and finished the multi-phase siege on 55 minutes. The first-half lineout wobbled: Australia took New Zealand ball and two of six throws were lost, which is never on the thrower alone. Came back on late after Aumua’s HIA.

7

1. Ethan de GrootLoosehead prop · c.48 min

Two first-half carries in 48 minutes, and not a word anywhere on his scrummaging.

7

All Blacks replacements: Aumua and Preston made Moorby’s try

16. Asafo AumuaHooker · c.23 min

Made Moorby’s try: after the drive he powered down the short side and fed Kyle Preston. Left late on for an HIA after clashing heads with teammate Anton Segner.

6.5

18. Pasilio TosiTighthead prop · c.22 min

Crashed over around 71 minutes, only for the TMO to rule it out for a knock-on at the ruck in the build-up. The knock-on wasn’t his. His scrummaging isn’t covered.

6

21. Kyle PrestonScrum-half · c.11 min

His flick pass finished the short-side move that sent Moorby over for the sixth try. Rugby.com.au and ABC blamed him for the ruck knock-on that cost Tosi a try. Sky Sports and Stuff named Rieko Ioane, so it hasn’t been counted against him.

6.5

23. Josh MoorbyWing · c.13 min

Finished the blindside move unmarked in the left corner for the sixth try. The work was done before the ball reached him, and nothing else from his 13 minutes made the reports.

6

Not rated, too little to go on: 17 George Bower (on 48 min), 19 Shannon Frizell (on 58 min), 20 Anton Segner (on 52 min, off after a head clash with Aumua), 22 Rieko Ioane (on 69 min).

Roigard is our All Blacks player of the match

Player of the match: Cam Roigard (9/10). McKenzie, with 15 points and the break that made New Zealand’s first try, runs him close.

Beauden Barrett without a mark is the call we expect to hear about. He played all 80 minutes, and none of the coverage described a kick, a catch or a tackle. We won’t invent a 7.

The sides meet again at Accor Stadium in Sydney on Saturday 17 October. Wrong call? Make the case in the comments.

More from the Bledisloe Cup

Every mark comes from live commentary and half-time stats

Full time: New Zealand 50-19 Australia (half-time 17-14), Eden Park, Auckland, Saturday 10 October 2026.

New Zealand 50. Tries: Peter Lakai, Tupou Vaa’i, Cam Roigard, Codie Taylor, Leroy Carter, Josh Moorby, Will Jordan. Conversions: Damian McKenzie 6. Penalty: McKenzie.

Australia 19. Tries: Tom Wright, Harry Wilson, Josh Nasser. Conversions: Ryan Lonergan 2.

Referee: Andrew Brace (Ireland). No cards were shown. The win takes the All Blacks’ unbeaten run at Eden Park from 53 Tests to 54.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies: an All Black in the black jersey dives over the line to score a try
Next up

All Blacks Player Ratings vs Wallabies: A 9 For Beauden Barrett

All Blacks player ratings vs Wallabies from the 43-21 win in Sydney: why Beauden Barrett gets a 9, Peter Lakai an 8.5, and a debutant the lowest mark.

New Zealand · 7 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?